I Might Be Wrong

I Might Be Wrong

Medicare For All Has a Loud Idiot Problem

Why are the biggest idiots always the loudest?

Jeff Maurer's avatar
Jeff Maurer
Nov 18, 2026
∙ Paid
A still from Ezra Klein’s New York Times interview with Hasan Piker.

Here’s an argument for Medicare For All that you may not have heard: There is no logical reason why health insurance should be mostly provided by employers. The US does it that way due to a historical accident, and the system is often complex and inefficient. Uninsured people drive up costs for everyone else, and the patchwork network of insurers and providers make pricing and quality difficult to determine for people who work in medicine and an indecipherable shadow ballet for everyone else.

One day, the US may have a national health care system for basic care and private insurance for everything else. If so, that day will be far in the future. What we have at the moment is a Medicare For All movement that seems to be mostly made up of strident know-nothings pushing the dumbest-possible version of a vapid slogan. It is less of a serious attempt to improve our healthcare system and more of an performative hissy fit by people who seem to have learned about healthcare from a bumper sticker that they half-read while drunk. And it threatens the prospects for real reform in the future.

“Performative hissy fit by people who seem to have learned about healthcare from a bumper sticker that they half-read while drunk” is a strong charge, so let me back it up. Here’s Hasan Piker hinting at the unfathomable depths of his ignorance on the issue that he claims is his main priority:

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Jeff Maurer.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Jeff Maurer · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.