98 Comments
User's avatar
Eric Blair's avatar

It's confusing only if you accept the very deliberately confusing framing of the transgender activists. To transgender activists (and to most of the media which diligently adhere to the activists' framing), the issue is about "'trans women' in sports. In the real world, the debate is about men in women's sports.

The resolution in the real world is simple, not confusing: Men can't compete in women's sports. The concept of "gender" or "gender identity" is completely irrelevant to this. It doesn't matter if Lia Thomas says he identifies as a woman or if Imane Khelif does or does not identify as "trans." Men may not compete in women's sports.

Marc Ethier's avatar

I'd go with "genetic males", or maybe "genetic males with a level of testosterone higher than would be normal for women", rather than "men". It's true that transgender activists have muddled the issue, and it's even true that they've instrumentalized the existence of intersex people as part of their crusade to pretend that self-declared gender identity should trump biological sex in all cases, but the fact is intersex people still exist. I'm perfectly fine with Caster Semenya or Imane Khelif not being allowed to compete in the women's category. But the "anti-woke" framing that we see in some heterodox spaces, which I totally agree was developed in response to the transgender activist framing, appears to be that all so-called "trans women" are actually AGP sexually predatory men, and then extends this to people like Semenya or Khelif who aren't even actually trans.

It's not a better framing. There needs to be rules about who can compete in the women's category, and the IOC's surrendering to transgender activist viewpoints isn't going to lead to a satisfactory resolution. But I think it's also not useful to insist on calling Caster Semenya or Imane Khelif "men", using "he/him" pronouns for them, blaming them for "invading women's spaces" (you didn't do this, but I've seen something like this before in other comment sections), or insisting that they need to use the men's bathroom.

Oh, and Jeff: I don't know what the law is like in Algeria, but just because sexual activity between people of the same sex is illegal there doesn't necessarily mean that transitioning to the other gender is as well. In the West we tend to view trans as "like gay, but more controversial", but I remember a long time ago seeing a documentary about gay men in Iran (where homosexual activity is of course also illegal) transitioning to a female identity so that they could have sex with (and possibly marry? I don't quite remember) their partners. This was apparently allowed by the government.

Ghatanathoah's avatar

Algeria does not legally recognize the existence of trans people or have any legal process to change your gender. You are correct about Iran's policies, but Algeria does not share them.

Tom Hitchner's avatar

What’s the justification for calling Khelif a “man,” when she was identified as a girl by her doctors, raised as a girl by her parents, and treated as a woman by her society, all using the same criteria that humans have relied on for nearly our entire history?

Haley's avatar

Khelif is NOT treated as a woman in his society. Just the fact that he was riding on his coaches shoulders at the Olympic demonstrates that. No way would a woman be allowed to do that in his culture. Based on the DSD he has, Khelif likely has ambiguous genitalia, similar to a micro penis. He has internal testicles that produce male levels of testosterone and no uterus or ovaries. He is a male and is treated as a man in his culture. It’s purposefully obtuse to pretend otherwise.

Tom Hitchner's avatar

“Khelif is NOT treated as a woman in his society. Just the fact that he was riding on his coaches shoulders at the Olympic demonstrates that. No way would a woman be allowed to do that in his culture.”

Gonna need a link for this bit of cultural semiotics.

Haley's avatar

In Islam it is forbidden for a believer to touch a member of the opposite sex that they are not related to.

For example, UFC fighter Khabib Nurmagomedov, who is also a devout Muslim, refused to shake the hand of female TV presenter Kate Scott at the UEFA Champions League. That’s because it would be a major transgression in his culture to touch a woman even on the hand

Imane Khelif was lifted onto the shoulders of his coach at the Olympics. In his culture, a woman spreading her legs and pressing her vagina against the neck of her coach while riding on his shoulders in public or private but especially on live television, would be a shocking transgression of the cultural norms. But Khelif doesn’t have a vagina, he is treated as a man in his culture, so it was fine.

Khelif grew up in the northwestern rural town of Biban Mesbah in the Tiaret province of Algeria and was raised as a devout Muslim.

Kurt Gehlen's avatar

Are you suggesting that theres no biological component to sex? Or that because people in the past had less information available to them and made categorization errors that we should continue make them today?

Tom Hitchner's avatar

“Are you suggesting that theres no biological component to sex?”

Of course not.

“Or that because people in the past had less information available to them and made categorization errors that we should continue make them today?”

Whether these were errors at all is what’s under dispute. We gender entities without reference to sex all the time. That’s separate from the question of who should be eligible to compete in women’s sports.

Kurt Gehlen's avatar

Do we gender entities without regard to sex? We describe things as masculine or feminine, meaning that they have characteristics generally associated with a particular sex, but I wouldnt call that assigning them a gender. Whats an example of this?

Eric Blair's avatar

The various things that you mention are not what determines sex in humans. "Identified as," "raised as," "treated as" are culturally variable, subjective, and irrelevant to a person's sex, which is an objective reality. The objective reality of Khelif's sex is that he is a man. The fact that his is a man is the justification for calling him a man.

Tom Hitchner's avatar

The factors I mentioned are certainly culturally variable and subjective, but that's at least as relevant as objective fact when determining what to call someone. Objectively, my given name is Thomas; there's not a legal document anywhere in the world that refers to me as Tom, yet Tom is what I go by and if you persisted in calling me Thomas even after I had asked you to use Tom, you'd be considered rude. For that matter, I've got one of your books on my shelf right in front of me, but it says George Orwell, even though objectively there was no such person!

Eric Blair's avatar

Everything you write here is true, but you've swerved quite a bit from the topic at hand.

Given names are in fact changeable and malleable, amenable to nicknames, diminutives, and noms de plume, and that is a reflection of the fact that given names are largely arbitrary. But of course a person's sex (what we're discussing here) is not in any way arbitrary. It simply is what it is.

Similarly, the question of who belongs in women's sports is not a matter of what it is rude to say, but merely what is true. If you're referring to Khelif as a woman because you think he might be reading comment threads on Substack and you don't want to hurt his feelings when he comes across your post, but you don't actually believe he's a woman, that's one thing. If you're referring to him as a woman because you think he's actually a woman despite the fact that he is a man, that's another thing entirely. But if you think he belongs in women's sports because it would be rude to say that he's not a woman, you're prioritizing politeness over truth, and that does not seem to be a defensible position.

Brad's avatar

He has XY chromosomes = man. It’s not complicated.

Pan Narrans's avatar

It is complicated, because she presents as female. She was identified (not "assigned") as female at birth and probably had no reason to question any of this until people started asking questions about her chromosomes. By the same token, I've never looked into my genetics but take it as read that I'm male as I have a dick and stuff.

Yeah, "XY" is the easiest definition of a male (unless it's "sperm producer") but it's simply not reasonable to act as if Khelif is a person born male who has decided to identify as female, still less a CIS man pretending to be female so he can win the Punching Women Competition.

We have these categories called "male" and "female" that upwards of 99% of the population fit into easily, but a few don't, for reasons that are physical, not psychological.

Tom Hitchner's avatar

Yeah, it’s plenty simple, I just can’t wrap my head around the idea that the anti-trans movement is treating it as self-evident that external genitalia is irrelevant to the question of how we classify someone as a man or a woman.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 19, 2025
Comment deleted
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 19, 2025
Comment deleted
Tom Hitchner's avatar

That’s just begging the question! You’re repeating the point under dispute.

Ghatanathoah's avatar

Khelif isn't trans or a man though. The whole reason this debate is so stupid is that the athlete that prompted this round of it is a woman.

Eric Blair's avatar

Are you saying that Khelif is an actual woman, as opposed to a trans woman?

How exactly would this situation be different if Khelif were trans?

Ghatanathoah's avatar

Yes, Khelif is an actual woman who is not trans.

I am saying that it is really dumb that the cause celebre that motivated this latest round of the debate is a regular woman, not a trans woman. A bunch of people saw a woman boxer whose face looked mannish to them and suddenly declared that she was a man beating up women, even though she is from a country that doesn't legally recognize the existence of trans people.

Your entire comment I was replying to was about trans activists and not allowing men in women's sports even if they say they are trans women. So the fact that Khelif is not a trans woman seems like a pretty important data point. Khelif's parents have shared pictures of her from when she was a little girl. She has clearly always been one, she is not a man who transitioned later in life.

Some people have asserted that Khelif might have a genetic condition that makes her body more masculine than is typical for a woman. That isn't impossible, but she is still clearly a woman, otherwise she wouldn't have been raised as one for decades in a conservative religious country.

MarkS's avatar

"Imane Khelif’s sex-test results from the 2023 World Championships have been published for the first time, with the medical report appearing to indicate that the boxer is biologically male."

https://www.yahoo.com/news/medical-report-leaked-proves-imane-182447965.html

MarkS's avatar

"To transgender activists (and to most of the media which diligently adhere to the activists' framing), the issue is about "'trans women' in sports. In the real world, the debate is about men in women's sports."

And we have to put Jeff in this sad category of "media diligently adhering to activists' framing".

My paid subscription expires tomorrow. I won't be renewing.

Eric Blair's avatar

Well, in his defense he does stipulate at the outset that he might be wrong.

Haley's avatar

Khelif is no kind of woman. Not genetically, not by his sexual organs, and not culturally either. Khelif is male and has no place in female sports.

JorgeGeorge's avatar

Get well soon Jeff!

The world needs you!

Filk's avatar

How do we test for gender again?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 19, 2025Edited
Comment deleted
Filk's avatar

No worries. My statement was intentionally goading to make a point. And pretty sure a point with which you, and many, may agree.

Brad's avatar

These two words are only used in “blatantly manipulative ways” by the “trans women are women” crowd, who spent twenty or so years smugly lecturing all of us that gender is different from sex (okay), but anytime it’s convenient for them (e.g. the passport debate) they conflate the two. Although this debate isn’t a trans issue, these two DSD guys and their defenders are doing the same linguistic trick.

Filk's avatar

Hm seems like I responded incorrectly to the wrong thread. Yes, I completely co-sign your assessment.

Brad's avatar

MOST languages don’t have a separate word for “gender.” (Even Danish doesn’t, and surgical sex reassignment started in Denmark.) Because in English we use the word “sex” probably more often to refer to the sex act, there’s been a prudish tendency to use “gender” as an alternative, the way Victorians supposedly avoided the word leg as being too racy (or something).

Filk's avatar

Well sure, but this language game is used in blatantly manipulative ways. I’m not accusing anyone here of doing that, just pointing it out.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 19, 2025Edited
Comment deleted
Filk's avatar

Paragraph 4, “The IBA says that Kehlief twice failed an unspecified gender test that apparently was not a test of testosterone levels…”

No, I don’t mean sex. I know how we test for sex. I do not know how we test for gender.

I’m making a very important rhetorical point.

Lauren B's avatar

May I suggest that part of why this debate has become so confusing for some is in part thanks to people in media and with other platforms who refer to men as "she", solidifying in the minds of those less attuned to the post-modern tactics of trans activism that these individuals must be women of some kind. They are not, and they should not be referred to as such if you want to be part of the solution rather than the problem. You don't need to call them "he" if you don't think the evidence is strong enough that Khelif has 5-ARD same as Semenya (which is confirmed beyond all doubt) which is an undisputed male DSD. But maybe don't participate in the notion these men's feelings are more important than facts and reality- and actual women- and people won't be so confused.

Ghatanathoah's avatar

Khelif and Semenya are women, though. They are not any kind of trans. They were both born with vaginas. Neither of them has ever had a penis. If you are going around telling someone who has a naturally occurring vagina that she is a man and that you don't care about her feelings, you are seriously deranged.

Lauren B's avatar

You are incorrect. Semenya has 5-ARD beyond all doubt thanks to his CAS case, and there is evidence that suggests Khelif does too. Please research 5-ARD and you will find the scientific and medical communities universally refer to those with 5-ARD as men, because they are male. This condition causes males that do not get the effects of DHT, which merely results in no male-pattern facial hair or baldness, and in utero- causes the genitals to not fully mature. But they are still male genitals. It results in a micro penis and internal testes that do not descend to testicles. And the path that they are supposed to descend results in a cavity at birth that along with the micro-penis can be confused with female genitalia in places without adequate medical care. But that cavity is NOT a vagina and those testes produce sperm, and these males are capable of fathering children though usually with some help.

Semenya is fully aware he is male. He knew exactly what he was doing competing in women's events- which is cheating. So forgive me if I don't care about his feelings.

Ghatanathoah's avatar

So you are saying that Semenya doesn't have a vagina, she has a naturally occurring cavity between her legs? That's what a vagina is. People with 5-ARD have a micro-penis located near the top of that cavity? That is called a clitoris. They have organs that produce gametes inside their torso instead of hanging outside their body? People who have those are typically called "women."

Remember that all mammals are initially female. The Y chromosomes just sends signals that tweaks a few body parts to masculinize them. In the case of 5-ARD that process is disrupted and not completed. That doesn't make someone with 5-ARD a man, that would be like saying someone who enrolled in an MD program and then dropped out is a doctor.

You seem to have this idea that if someone has a mix of male and female characteristics, that makes them male automatically, sort of like a "one drop rule" for sex. It makes more sense to say that they are biologically neither male nor female, or that they are a female that began to develop into a male, but stopped.

Lauren B's avatar

What a disgusting thing to say. A vagina is not just any old hole in that general region, it is a legitimate organ with unique properties. You are reducing women's anatomy to what men think our anatomy is- just a hole to penetrate- and you really should be ashamed.

Lauren B's avatar

Women don't pee or ejaculate sperm out of our clitoris, which is what a 5-ARD micro penis will do. You seem intent on defining male and female features by the most shallow appearances rather than function- which isn't helpful. Where is the cutoff that a penis that pees and ejaculates becomes small enough that it is considered a clitoris? Is it the same size that a clitoris that doesn't pee or ejaculate becomes a penis?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 19, 2025
Comment deleted
Marc Ethier's avatar

So your assertion is that the pictures of people with complete androgen insensitivity on the Wikipedia article about this condition (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complete_androgen_insensitivity_syndrome) are of people who should unambiguously be considered men and not women, and treated in society as belonging to the masculine gender (for example, use "he/him" pronouns as well as the men's bathroom)? Would this really make things less confusing?

Note that this has nothing to do about whether said people should be allowed to compete in the women's category at the Olympic games. Though I would say that I think the onus should be on sports' regulating organizations to put in place tenable rules about who can compete in the women's category, and not on individual athletes to somehow decide they ought not to compete as women, even if they might have been socialized as girls and women for their whole lives.

Lauren B's avatar

I think someone's sex is irrelevant in most cases but where it matters it REALLY matters. I am happy to consider DSDs individually and be polite to males with unfortunate circumstances of birth up until they use my kindness to shit on women. Then I'm going to insist on brutal truths.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 19, 2025Edited
Comment deleted
Tom Hitchner's avatar

"Semenya is fully aware he is male." Based on what do you draw this conclusion?

Lauren B's avatar

Based on his CAS case. When one sues one's sport governing body over one's physiology, the facts about said physiology are part of discovery. He and his legal team agreed that he has 5-ARD and internal testes. He is on tape talking about how his testes don't make him less of a woman. He is married to a woman and has children with her. While he will never confirm they are his biologically, there is no reason they can't be. Would you use donor sperm if you were perfectly capable of creating your own?

Tom Hitchner's avatar

Yeah, the position that there’s no such thing as gender, only sex, AND that sex is solely about chromosomes (hence undetectable to the naked eye) is as radical and detached from traditional practice as total self-ID is.

Lauren B's avatar

No one intelligent is saying sex is solely about chromosomes. Semenya is male because of his testes.

Brad's avatar

The concept of “gender” exists, of course, but why the heck would it be relevant in sports? Sports are played with bodies, not “gender identities.” XY out of XX sports, end of story, find another hobby!

Tom Hitchner's avatar

Right, I'm not talking about her participation in sports, but whether Khelif is properly called a man, he, etc., as Lauren was doing. I was agreeing with someone who finds that incorrect.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 19, 2025
Comment deleted
Ghatanathoah's avatar

People with 5-ARD don't just not have a penis, they typically have a vaginal opening and a rectouterine pouch (although each case is different). Many of them can have PIV sex. It's absurd to tell someone with a naturally occurring opening in the front of their crotch that they have used to have sex with guys that they are a man.

Chris Fehr's avatar

This will be abused by individuals and countries that care more about medals for the country than any spirit of the rules. Very quickly a man that only ever entered one race as non-binary used it to qualify for the Boston marathon. With almost nothing on the line, no fame, glory or money people are willing to cheat. Make it easier and more socially acceptable and it will only grow.

J. J. Ramsey's avatar

Has anyone else noticed that "Khelif" was spelled more than one way in this post, such as "Khelief" and "Kehlief"?